Lexisnexis

LexisNexis Corporate & Securities Law Community 2011 Top 50 Blogs

Bon mots

"You can observe a lot just by watching." Yogi Berra

"We do not distain to borrow wit or wisdom from any man who is capable of lending us either." Henry Fielding, Tom Jones

"In our complex society the accountant's certificate and the lawyer's opinion can be instruments for inflicting pecuniary loss more potent than the chisel or the crowbar." United States v. Benjamin, 328 F.2d 854, 862 (2d Cir. 1964)
Showing posts with label protective order. Show all posts
Showing posts with label protective order. Show all posts

Protective Order Granted - Division of Enforcement Brief Sealed

Nature's Sunshine Products, Inc., Exchange Act Rel. 59181, December 30, 2008

Nation's Sunshine is the subject of a proceeding to revoke its registration due to delinquent periodic filings. The company moved to seal the Division of Enforcement's supplemental brief on appeal arguing that the brief contains confidential information concerning an unrelated Commission formal order of investigation (authorizing Commission staff to issue investigative subpoenas). The Commission concluded without discussion or analysis that "harm resulting from complete disclosure outweighs the benefits" and ordered the Division's brief sealed.

Routine Protective Order Granted

Joseph John VanCook, Exchange Act Rel. 58756 (October 8, 2008)

As is its practice in appeals, the Commission granted a protective order sealing tax returns filed by an appellant in his pending appeal.  Respondents often file such financial information in an effort to claim an inability to pay either disgorgement or penalties.

Protective Order Issued

Thomas C. Bridge, Exchange Act Rel. 58329 (August 7, 2008)

As is routine practice, the Commission issued a protective order for tax returns Mr. Bridge filed in connection with his pending appeal of an ALJ's initial decision.  Respondents usually provide financial information on appeal when they seek to support a claim they are unable to pay disgorgement or penalties ordered by the ALJ.  The ALJ's initial decision where she ordered Bridge to pay a $250,000 penalty is available here.

Protective Orders Granted

Thomas C. Bridge, James D. Edge, Jeffrey K. Robles, Securities Act Rels. 33-8937, 8938, 3939 (June 30, 2008)

Summary

These respondents submitted personal financial information to the Commission in connection with their appeal of an ALJs initial decision.  Usually this is done to attempt to eliminate or reduce penalties or disgorgement based on an argument of inability to pay.  The Commission pursuant to its Rule of Practice 322 generally grants protective orders making such information non-public.

Protective Order Granted For Financial Information In Connection With Appeal

Gregory O. Trautman, Exchange Act Release 57545

As is its practice, the Commission granted a protective order sealing certain personal and confidential financial information Trautman filed in connection with his pending appeal of an ALJ's initial decision that can be viewed here  (also see the ALJ's  denial of a motion to correct here).  Respondents typically file such information in an effort to establish an "inability to pay" defense to disgorgement or penalties.

David Henry Disraeli and Lifeplan Associates, Inc., Exchange Act Rel. 56012, July 5, 2007

Protective order

The Commission granted a protective order concerning personal financial information submitted by a respondent in a proceeding pursuant to Rule 322.